They Say, I Say

1. The introduction title is "Entering the Conversation" this reveals that as a research/argumentative writer, we need to be involved in the conversation and be able and willing to give our own input. Our role is we need to add information into the conversation, involve ourselves so we can gain all the info necessary for our research. Also as argumentative writers, us as writers need to be understanding and willing to listen to all sides of every story, not just be one-sided and believe our own personal views are the only views.
2. The "They Say, I Say" formula is important in your research writing because not only do you want to include your opinion but you also need to include what others have to say. To argue it is helpful to include both sides or positions on the topic, so the audience has enough background knowledge to agree or disagree with the presented information. All good academic writing will provide the audience with both sides of an issue not just a one-sided paper.
3. After looking at the templates in "Ways of Responding" the purpose of these templates are to set up a way to disagree or agree on the topic, at a sentence level. It shows me that it is important to include your position and these templates allow you to do so in an easy smooth way. We should consider using them because they help enhance writing, without your stance on a topic, your writing will be flat.
4. The Dr, X story illustrates that a writer or speaker needs to clearly indicate their thesis, but also they need to clearly state their opinion on the thesis and how they are responding to it. If they disagree or not.
5. -Common sense seems to dictate that_________    -My whole life I have heard it said that_________     -At the same time I believe________, I also believe_________
6. The most common response when responding is a in between response, meaning the person does not want to totally agree or disagree for many different reasons. Sometimes they don't want to have to explain themselves so they do this, other times they want to see what others say. Our responses to everyday texts influence reactions and answers to other topics. 
7. It is a good tactic to not directly jump into a mass of detail, but state clearly whether you agree or not with heh subject.
8. I think I am going to write critically about: a music video, and examine issues of gender, and societal norms within this media. When I pull back the curtain some of the messages I see are how they objectify and sexualize women and how these videos set a societal norm on appearance and actions. What I want others to understand through my analysis is these videos form a toxic environment for children growing up surrounded by and watching them. They should promote positive messages in attempt to boost confidence levels not drag them down. They need to stop promoting the wrong ideas.

Music Videos Representation of Women

Watching many music videos today, you see women constantly wearing little to no clothing. They are surrounding a fancy or wealthy scene, sitting on cars or expensive boats. The are presented as objects and are there to help advertise and essentially sell the image or scene presented. It is worth noting that they sometimes are seen with alcoholic beverages and I think this is not by accident.  Sometimes the women are doing things or are framed to look unintelligent and uneducated. They are positioned in a way when seated or standing to show off a part of their body. These women tend to where small or tight bathing suits or inappropriate clothing. Not to mention, they are covered in makeup to help enhance their beauty because these videos love to follow the societal beauty norm. These images are often unrealistic as well, you will see a women in a bathing suit but yet she will have her hair perfectly curled and a full face of professional makeup done. When you analyze and dig deeper into the actual scenes presented in these music videos it really shows the intent of the video. These videos are trying to sell certain ideas and promote certain images, these images are not what children growing up today should believe to be the "norm".  These things are shown in many music videos today and it is devastating and unfortunate to witness. I am thinking about writing about music videos.

Critique #4: Video games or Music

Choice 2: Music

Many music videos today, this one included sexualizes women and makes them look like objects. The  women have no lyrics or actions, they honestly are just placed in the video to help enhance the male leaders "reputation". There are many things wrong with these music videos. First of all most women in these videos are wearing little to no clothing and are again portraying society's ideal image of beauty. This can be related to the quote “...The image isn’t real; it’s artificial, it’s constructed.” This quote is true even in music videos, these women are altered and edited. They do not always look so flawless, they have loads of makeup to help them fit into societal beauty "norm". Second, these videos constantly promote the same images. They show a successful male figure in a wealthy car or boat, wearing designer clothing, with women who are beautiful and half naked. These women act like their counter parts, they are not presented as people. This relates to the quote “...turning  a human being into a thing is almost always the first step toward justifying violence against that person.” This quote clearly exemplifies how women are constantly treated like objects and counter parts, which does nothing but hurt their confidence and allow men to believe this idea is okay, which it is not! We need to think critically watching these videos because many people view these music videos growing up, and then they constantly compare themselves to these women and get this image of them acting like objects in their head, this is a toxic environment created. Not only do the videos create this sad image but the lyrics also present many degrading and dehumanizing ideas about women.

Quotes and Connections

"Movies are a 'lead propaganda machine' working against equal rights movements for women and minorities. Movies, and popular media, have the potential to reverse the progress made toward eradicating intolerance and bigotry in society today"

I agree with my quote. It explains how movies are leading propaganda and really promoting racial and gender stereotypes that are offensive. This quote relates to my previous critiques because it shows how directors are purposefully placing certain actors of a certain race or appearance or gender into a movie because they think this is what will make the movie more appealing for viewers, meanwhile it is just working against equal rights movements for minorities and women. Many movies today still sexualize women and make them helpless characters who are society idea of "beautiful" but can't speak or fight back for themselves. Movies also may place someone of color as the criminal in a scene, because they are playing off of stereotypes and feels that makes the most sense, it doesn't. This is extremely degrading and is making society take steps backwards, rather than progress forward, when fighting for equal rights for women and minorities. I agree with this quote and believe we all need to come together in order to put a stop toward this, because the world needs to be moving forward and taking strides toward equality, not get kicked backwards due to popular culture events (such as movies, advertisements, ect.)

My peers had similar ideas, they connected the ideas presented in the quote to motivated representations shown in Hooks analysis of movies and directors. I really liked what others said about how when kids are young they are not capable of telling what is wrong versus right and what they should watch versus what they shouldn't. This is important because it all starts when you are young. It all starts when you can't consciously choose what shows you watch are good or bad so you just end up watching cartoons which then in turn can correlate with stereotypes. Young brains are then introduced to societal standards or what is considered "normal". Kids think that they should look or act a certain way based on stereotypes presented to them in movies and media today. Also, we can choose to ignore lots of media or movies but we are all surrounded by it and one way or another are influenced by it.

Critique #3: Bell Hooks

In Hook's interview she says "Part of the power of Cultural Criticism is to say that there really is a conscious manipulation of representations. Media is not about magical thinking, it's not about pure imagination or creativity, it's about people consciously knowing what kinds of images will create a certain impact [on viewers]." This quote is interesting because it is true and prevalent today in movies and advertisements we are surrounded by. The quotes presented explain that people especially directors of movies are consciously knowing what images produce a certain impact. People continue to promote stereotypes because they feel this is what people in our world today will respond to. A more recent movie that plays on stereotypes would be the movie Kissing Booth. This movie presents the young girl as an object, she is constantly being fought over by guys and seems to be passed off like it's not a big deal.

Critique #2: Kid Stuff

The ideas encountered in the above texts explain that shows children of young ages are exposed to, are stereotypical and frankly bad influences on the children. Many Disney movies tend to frame generic characters and present them in stereotypical ways. These movies only show heterosexual relationships, where the male is extremely masculine, and follows all these unspoken rules about his appearance. Usually, the men are the hero and the woman is the one swept off her feet, who is thin and pretty. Not to mention almost, if not all are white characters. I agree in believing that these are bad for children to watch and then believe they need to look or behave certain ways. Writers critique Disney by showing their use of stereotypes, they also do say that sometimes Disney is emphasizing the women's power, such as Mulan. She plays a significant female role in a Disney film.The broader messages are children should not grow up thinking these things are the norm, because it makes them become judgmental of others and themselves. TV shows such as Doc Mcstuffins, need to be present and available for all children so they grow up learning and understanding that everyone is different and they should love themselves. Also, these education shows teach young kids important principles
about life and being safe. When I was younger I loved Mulan. Today I see that the movie really hypes up the stereotypical ideals of a mans appearance. In the following clip, the movie sums up what a man should look like and be able to do strength wise.

Counter Culture

Today, after listening to Guante's poem, it truly opens up the idea to everyone that ads today and stereotypes that are heavily listened to are degrading and wrong. No man or women should ever have to be judged or judge themselves based on their appearance and who they are. Unfortunately the world today shaped our views and has effected every single person in this world, whether the believe it or not. We are surrounded with images, phrases, stereotypes that constantly make us rethink who we are and make many of us follow unspoken rules to be "normal". What is normal, cisgender, is a word that essentially means you grew up to be a boy when you were born male, or you grew up to be  girl when you were born a female. This word is attempting to make you think,  this word attempts to denormalize the idea of being normal. In my opinion it accomplishes this, and makes the audience think about titles and if they really matter.  Yes I am a female who grew up to be a confident girl, I am cisgender. This word can easily come off as weird to others because it seems different because maybe it sounds like transgender, because it is not normal, but it is nothing to be ashamed of. It shows that anyone should be able to associate themselves with what they want. No one, no ads, no images, no society should tell them who they have to be.